/ Guides & Explainers / By

The Good Character Requirement in Settlement Applications: Why Previous Overstaying May Still Count Against You

If you’re applying for Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR) in the UK, particularly on the 10-year route, you need to understand that the Home Office is applying the good character requirement more strictly than many people realise.

A common—and potentially costly—misconception is that overstaying before your 10-year continuous residence period is automatically disregarded. While there’s some truth to this, the reality is more nuanced, and getting it wrong could mean losing your £2,885 application fee with no refund.

Understanding the Good Character Requirement for Settlement

The good character requirement applies to most Settlement applications. It’s not just about criminal convictions—the Home Office considers your entire immigration history, including:

  • Previous overstaying
  • Breaches of immigration conditions
  • Illegal working
  • Deception or non-disclosure
  • Compliance with UK laws generally

The requirement is set out in Appendix Good Character and in Home Office guidance, but the application of these rules in practice is often stricter than applicants expect.

The 10-Year Route Misconception

Many applicants on the 10-year route to Settlement believe that any overstaying that occurred before their 10-year qualifying period started is completely disregarded. This is partially correct, but with critical exceptions.

What Actually Happens

The Home Office does generally focus on your conduct during the relevant qualifying period. However, previous immigration history—including overstaying—can still be considered when assessing good character if it involved:

Illegal working: Working without permission during a period of overstaying demonstrates a more serious breach than simply remaining in the UK without valid leave.

Absconding: If you deliberately avoided contact with the Home Office or failed to comply with reporting requirements, this shows a pattern of non-compliance that weighs against you.

Deception: Any use of false documents, false information, or attempts to mislead immigration authorities will be considered regardless of when it occurred.

Serious or persistent breaches: Multiple periods of overstaying or particularly lengthy overstaying may still be relevant even if outside the qualifying period.

The Real-World Impact

In our experience, the Home Office increasingly refuses Settlement applications from people who assume their earlier overstaying “doesn’t count.” Even if you’ve maintained lawful residence for 10 years, previous illegal working or absconding during an earlier period of overstaying can lead to refusal on good character grounds.

This is particularly problematic because:

  1. ILR application fees are not refundable—you lose £2,885 if refused
  2. You may face a “cooling off” period before you can reapply
  3. A refusal on your record can complicate future applications
  4. You may need to leave the UK if your current leave expires

Timing Your Application Safely

Given the strict application of good character requirements, timing is crucial. Here’s what you need to consider:

Know Your Full Immigration History

Before applying for Settlement, you should:

  • Obtain your full immigration history through a Subject Access Request to the Home Office
  • Identify any periods of overstaying, illegal working, or non-compliance
  • Calculate exactly when these incidents occurred
  • Assess how they might be viewed under current good character guidance

Consider the Relevant Periods

Different aspects of your immigration history remain relevant for different periods:

  • Criminal convictions: Non-custodial sentences are usually considered for 12 months; custodial sentences for longer periods depending on length
  • Immigration breaches: Generally considered if within the qualifying period, but serious breaches may be considered for longer
  • Deception: Can be considered indefinitely

Assess Whether You Meet the Requirement Now

If your immigration history includes concerning elements, you need to honestly assess:

  • How serious were the breaches?
  • How long ago did they occur?
  • Have you maintained lawful residence since then?
  • Is there evidence of rehabilitation or changed circumstances?

Sometimes waiting an additional period with completely clean compliance is the safer approach than risking an immediate application.

Getting Professional Advice

The good character requirement is discretionary and fact-specific. What leads to refusal in one case might be acceptable in another, depending on:

  • The specific nature and seriousness of the breach
  • How long ago it occurred
  • Your conduct since
  • Any mitigating circumstances
  • How well your case is presented

This is why professional legal advice is essential before making a Settlement application if you have any doubts about meeting the good character requirement.

What We Can Help With

At Migrant Law Partnership, we can:

  • Review your complete immigration history and identify potential good character issues
  • Advise on the strength of your application under current Home Office policy
  • Recommend the safest timing for your application
  • Prepare representations addressing any concerns in your history
  • Help you gather evidence of good character to support your case

The Cost of Getting It Wrong

An unsuccessful ILR application doesn’t just mean losing the application fee. It can have serious consequences:

  • Financial loss: £2,885 in application fees, plus legal fees if you used a solicitor
  • No refund: Home Office fees are non-refundable regardless of the outcome
  • Immigration status: If your current leave expires, you may need to leave the UK or apply for further leave
  • Future applications: A refusal on your record may complicate future applications
  • Uncertainty and stress: The emotional and practical impact of an unexpected refusal

These consequences make it crucial to get the timing and assessment right the first time.

Making a Safe Application

If you’re considering applying for Settlement, particularly on the 10-year route, and you have any concerns about previous overstaying, illegal working, or other compliance issues:

  1. Don’t assume previous breaches are automatically disregarded
  2. Obtain your full immigration history before applying
  3. Seek professional advice on whether you meet the good character requirement now
  4. Consider timing carefully—sometimes waiting longer is safer than rushing an application
  5. Prepare your case properly with evidence and representations addressing any concerns

The good character requirement is being applied strictly. What might have been overlooked in the past is now leading to refusals. With such a substantial non-refundable fee at stake, it’s worth investing in proper advice to ensure your application is made at the right time and in the right way.

Need advice on your Settlement application? Contact Migrant Law Partnership for a consultation. We can review your immigration history, assess your good character position, and advise on the safest timing for your application.

Call us on 02071128163 or email hello@migrantlawpartnership.come  to arrange a consultation.